Middle AgesMiddle Ages (13th–14th centuries AD) · Svendborg, Denmark
Freshwater fish made medieval Danish monastery burials look centuries older than the monasteries
A skeleton buried in Svendborg's Franciscan friary dated to about AD 1100–1155, though the friary was founded only in 1236, and five more of 27 burials have the same problem.

In brief 3 key points
ShowHide
- Researchers re-examined radiocarbon dates of 27 people buried at medieval Danish monasteries
- Six skeletons, including III9B from Svendborg, date to before their monastery was built
- Old carbon from freshwater fish in the diet made their bones look several hundred years too old
A person buried in a place of honour at the Franciscan monastery in Svendborg, Denmark, was radiocarbon dated to between AD 1100 and 1155. The monastery was founded only in 1236. The person, known as skeleton III9B, ate a lot of freshwater fish, and that made the bones look older than they were.
Kaare Lund Rasmussen and Jesper Lie Boldsen of the University of Southern Denmark and Johannes van der Plicht of the Center for Isotope Research in Groningen re-examined the dates of 27 people buried at Danish monasteries. They published their warning in the journal npj Heritage Science.
Six skeletons older than their churches
Denmark had about 140 medieval monasteries. People were buried in their cemeteries or inside the churches, so every burial must be later than the building. All 27 skeletons had high levels of the isotope nitrogen-15, a sign of freshwater fish in the diet.
Six of the 27 have radiocarbon dates that cannot fit the age of their monastery. One burial at the Monastery of Our Lady in Viborg has a date range ending in AD 976, more than 200 years before the monastery was built. Three burials at the Cistercian monastery at Øm show the same problem.
“The results make it abundantly clear that this is a major problem. And not just in Denmark, but probably across the rest of Europe too.”
Kaare Lund Rasmussen, University of Southern Denmark
Old carbon from lakes and rivers
Radiocarbon dating measures how much carbon-14 is left in a sample. Old carbon can leak from sediments along lake shores and riverbanks into the water. Fish from those waters then hold less carbon-14 than food from land, and so do the bones of people who eat a lot of them.
The size of the effect differs from one lake or river to the next, from zero to 1,000 years. In extreme cases a fish from the Rhine can look up to 1,300 years older than a land animal of the same time. That is why a simple correction does not work.
Sea fish also make bones look older, but more predictably. In the North Sea the effect is well established at around 400 years. The team urges anyone dating fish-eating humans or animals to watch for what they call the freshwater trap.
Sources (3)
Peer-reviewed paperfrom University of Southern Denmark and Center for Isotope Research, University of Groningen
- Freshwater fish in diets can make radiocarbon dates hundreds of years too old (Archaeology News)
- Fish can make skeletons appear hundreds of years too old (Archaeology Wiki)
- Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibilit (Heritage Science)
Paper: Rasmussen, van der Plicht and Boldsen, npj Heritage Science (2026)
Edited by Guiseppe Weijermars
Spotted a mistake? Tell the editor about a spelling error or a fact that is wrong. We correct stories openly.
